Is Hair Gel Killing Your Style? What to Use Instead

Jul 28

Hair gel has been a go-to styling product for decades. It’s cheap, easy to apply, and delivers that slicked-back, high-shine look we all grew up seeing on TV. But here’s the truth: if you’re still using traditional hair gel today, it could be killing your style.

From crunchy textures to flaky disasters, gel can actually hold your look back instead of pulling it together. Let’s break down why it might be time to ditch the gel—and explore smarter, more modern alternatives that give your hair hold without the stiffness.

Why Hair Gel Is Fading Out

Traditional hair gel may have earned its place in the grooming routine of the past, but it’s lost its edge for today’s more natural and versatile hairstyles. Here’s why:

1. Crunchy, Unnatural Texture

Gel hardens quickly, leaving your hair feeling brittle and immobile.
It often gives off an artificial shine that can look greasy or plastic-like in natural light.

2. Flaking and Residue

As gel dries out throughout the day, it tends to flake, especially if you run your hands through your hair.
This can make it look like you have dandruff—even if your scalp is perfectly clean.

3. Blocked Pores and Scalp Irritation

Many gels contain alcohol and synthetic ingredients that dry out the scalp and clog follicles.
Over time, this can lead to itchiness, irritation, or even stunt healthy hair growth.

4. Outdated Look

Gel-stiffened spikes or high-shine combovers feel more "high school dance" than "grown man with style."

Better Alternatives to Hair Gel

Luckily, there are much better options out there for styling your hair. These alternatives give you hold, volume, and flexibility—without the downsides of traditional gel.

1. Hair Clay

Ideal for men who want a matte finish and natural texture.
Works best for medium to short hairstyles that need a strong but flexible hold.
Easy to rework throughout the day without washing out.

2. Pomade

Offers a soft shine and smooth control—great for slick backs or side parts.
Oil-based pomades give long-lasting hold, while water-based versions are easier to wash out.
Perfect for classic looks that require polish but not stiffness.

3. Hair Cream

Lightweight, moisturizing, and great for guys with longer or wavier hair.
Provides a light hold while keeping hair soft and touchable.
Helps tame frizz and flyaways without clumping or crispiness.

4. Paste or Fiber

Fiber adds volume and thickness to thinner hair, while pastes offer medium hold with a natural finish.
Both options are great for creating controlled yet casual looks.

Choosing the Right Product for Your Hair Type

Still unsure which product fits your style best? Here are a few quick guidelines:

For fine or thinning hair: Try fiber or clay to add volume without weighing it down.
For thick or coarse hair: Pomade or paste works well to tame and define texture.
For curls or waves: Creams or soft-hold pastes keep your pattern in place without frizz.
For slick, structured styles: Water-based pomade offers the best of both worlds—shine and control.

Conclusion

Hair gel had its moment, but modern grooming calls for more refined, flexible products that work with your hair, not against it. Whether you're going for a textured crop, slick pompadour, or laid-back waves, ditching the gel could be the smartest move for your style.

Not sure where to start? At In The Cut Barbershop in Vancouver, we don’t just give you a fresh haircut—we guide you on the best styling products to suit your hair type and lifestyle. Book an appointment with us today, and leave with both a great cut and the know-how to keep it looking sharp. Let us help you elevate your grooming game from the roots up.